Putting into comparison the .308 and .30-06 is a different ball game from comparing to the .223. As noted above, the 30 Carbine Hornady FXT generates muzzle energy of 957 foot-pounds and the 223 Hornady V-Max 1019 foot-pounds. The .223 is much more powerful, but still on the small side for deer. The fact still remains that both the 308 and the 30 – 06 are big rounds. The little 7.62 Soviet does work on caribou based on what I have seen on probably less than half a dozen tundra deer, but weakly. That’s still not a heck of a lot to start with and it helps make this round a great recoil-sensitive, range-limited rifle round. It’s also the culmination of an all-out effort to achieve maximum .30-caliber velocity in the AR-15. 458 SOCOM. It offers more lethality ... .223 Remington 55 Grain HP by Hornady. It is a long gun with a shorter barrel length than a rifle that is chambered in a traditional pistol caliber as opposed to a dedicated rifle caliber such as .223/5.56, .308, or 7.62 NATO. Yes you can shoot a 223 at long range, but the 06 is better IMHO. What do y'all think about .45acp carbine vs. .223/5.56 for home defense (not talking 100 yards-plus, I've got a 5.56 20" AR for that). First hand experience here. 0.308" 155gn bullets need around 3,000 fps MV to be sure of staying supersonic at 1,000 yards, so a typical rifle for these disciplines has a 30" barrel minimum, sometimes up to 34", to get the necessary MV. You'll note that the .223 offers half again as much energy as the .30 carbine round, making it clearly the more "powerful" of the two rounds in terms of velocity or energy. The .30 Carbine has approximately the energy of a .38 special. V/E stands for "Velocity/Energy", and its measured at the muzzle and then as the projectile proceeds downrange. Don’t send a boy to do a man’s job. As illustrated in the chart, .223 Remington rounds - on average - achieve a velocity of about 3150 feet per second (fps) while .30 M1 Carbine rounds travel at a velocity of 1990 fps. The 5.56 ballistically is not better than the 30 Carbine out at 200 yards. SAAMI lists the maximum average pressure for .223 Remington ammo in a .223 chamber as 55,000 psi with bullets ranging from 35- to 77-grains traveling anywhere from 4,000 to 2,785 ft. per second velocity. Energy. 30-06 and 7.62X54R passed through. Handgun. .223 55gr.fmj and 7.62X39 123gr fmj much deeper crater around 1/4 inch deep. .30 Carbine. To put this into perspective, a Boeing 737 commercial airliner travels at a cruising speed of 600 mph, or 880 fps. .308. The difference between the two rounds comes down to their ability to handle maximum pressure. The AR-15 holds 20–30 rounds and the Winchester 5–6. on 1/12/14 at 5:31 pm to DeepSouthSportsman. If you plan on shooting long range in the future the 06 is the way to go. Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a .223 Remington round averages out to 1250 ft-lb, while a .30-30 Winchester round averages out to about 1890 ft-lb. The second major difference is the case length, as the 30-30 is over a half inch longer than the 7.62x39. There will be no contest when you look at the gel blocks. the .30 Carbine cartridge made by Hornady outperforms any pistol round that the majority of Americans will use in home defense. The brass lasts literally forever if you get good stuff, the powder loads are like pistols (9-14 grains) and the bullets are .30 cal so not really that expensive and easily found in bulk. It is very time consuming. I like the idea of the .223 because of the rounds it can hold and the rounds are cheaper to use and practice with. Rifle Recoil Table. Again, one of the rounds looked like it started tumbling. 1.Humans are more important than Hardware. The .30-caliber U.S. M1 carbine was arguably the first of the modern class of lightweight personal defense weapons (PDW). The 30-30 I believe is a 7 round mag, but a .223 (I'm thinking Mini-14, but don't have one yet) can hold a 20 or 30 round magazine. In the shooting sports we call that reaction recoil or "kick." It held a lot of ammo for the time and was extremely quick into action in a close fight. The .308 Winchester has a much longer case length (2.015″ vs 1.76″) and overall length (2.81″ vs 2.26″) than the .223 Rem. both absolutely smoke the 30 carbine. This in turn allows the 30-30 to have a higher case capacity of 45 gr H2O compared to 35.6 gr for the 7.62x39. Typical .223 Remington muzzle energies are around 1,100 to 1,300 foot-pounds. Tested along side a 50gr .223 JHP, a .30 carbine 110gr JSP will transfer energy much better according to tests with viscous fluid, clay, and enertia targets at ranges from 1 to 100 yds. So he decided to compare hardballs: 30 carbine vs 5.56 NATO. To see how these week calibers do against water jugs. Plus, the .30/30 carries nearly three times the .223’s bullet weight for a deeper punch. The 308 is stronger, thicker at the base, and operates at a chamber pressure. It would cost about $1200 with a good trigger and mid-range red-dot scope. A great rifle in the AR-15 series for self-defense in long range is the DPMS Sportical. This allows the 308 Win to fire a heavier bullet and keep it going for long range shooting, but all … If I had to take one, I would take the .223 loaded … In a rifle, the recoil of .357 Magnum is hard to distinguish from .223 Rem. 45-70 GOVT NEW. In comparison, a Double Tap 10mm 135-grain round generates 1555 fps and 725 foot-pounds of energy. 50 BEOWULF. The free-floating 5.56mm barrel has 1 in 7 right hand twist rifling. The biggest difference between the modern mindset in .223 and .30 Carbine is that you have to be a reloader to really want to go the .30 carbine route. Though the .308 is not as heavy as others, but considering the amount of ammo a regular hunter takes with himself, its not a concern. The increased case capacity and case length allows the 30-30 to fire heavier bullets than the 7.62x39. 2. There is no comparison! For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction; that is one of the physical laws of our universe. Next comes accuracy, and the 30 carbine did pretty well. The main difference between 5.56 & .223 Rem. While the .223 Remington has the advantage of speed, the .308 Winchester is the clear winner in energy. This translates to a gain of 0.260” (more than a quarter-inch) over the .300 BLK, resulting in a significant boost in velocity. Alongside the .25, .30 and .32 Remington, the .35 would be the only survivor. 50 BMG NEW. The Carbine was unique in that it was a breech-loading rifle that fired metallic cartridges fed from a 7 round tube magazine. You can find products above this level, but most will fall into these speeds. Palma, Fullbore (Target Rifle as we call it in the UK and British Commonwealth), and F/TR are limited to .308 Winchester and .223 Remington. First you have to run the cases into the trim die and rough cut the brass with a power saw--I used a jig saw with a metal blade. This is of course due to the 5.56 bullet moving at a much faster speed than the 30 carbine slugs. It is much flatter shooting. This means that the momentum of a rifle's reaction will exactly equal the momentum of the bullet and powder gasses ejected from the barrel. 308 WIN NEW. The idea was that the carbine … The second round made it through 11. 9mm-45 fmj’s indication of bullet impact,..30 carbine 110gr fmj , indention. Presented for your consideration are M4 style carbines with 16-inch barrels. 9mm carbines are nice, but budget ARs are cheaper. By one metric, the .223 beats the .30/30 hands down. Intended to arm soldiers who need lightweight arms, the PDW is a handy weapon that does not get in the way of other duties, such as driving a tank, manning a radio post or serving as an ammunition bearer. The 30 carbine was/is an excellent home defense round, although 5.56 and 300 BLK are now better. ... Its ballistics are inferior to the .30 Carbine..357 Magnum - This is a revolver cartridge adequate for shooting deer to about 50 yards. 5.56 NATO NEW. Put up a couple of couple of ballistic gel blocks at 100 yards. Because the CMMG 9mm carbine mimic the .223 version almost completely, the shooter loses very little when switch to the pistol caliber over rifle for training scenarios. a 30/30 launches a 150 or 170 grain Bullet . The parent case is, again, the 5.56×45 NATO (or .223), stretched beyond their 7.62×40 WT. (Ever seen a camo-clad wanna-be deer hunter with a .223 AR carbine?) 300 Blackout vs 223 Recoil. I think you let him try the 30/30 and if that works, and you want to buy him a youth model rifle then the .243 would be perfect. 243 80gr sp bullet pushed it’s nose through. One model chambers the 5.56mm/.223 Remington round and the other the 9x19mm round. Generally, a 30-30 round has a velocity of about 2,370 fps, while 308 travels at a speed of 2,680 fps. The 30/30 is a deer and black bear cartridge whereas the 223 is a varmint and medium game up to but not including deer. You be the judge and let me know your thoughts. Next, the .30 Carbine. The .223 will do incredible damage, far beyond anything the 9mm will accomplish. In the 110-130 grain supersonic rounds, it’s nearly 50% more. A 223 or 5.56 (same cartridge) launches a 55–68 grain bullet significantly faster. This post was edited on 1/12 at 5:32 pm. The 5.56, which is essentially .22 caliber, produced much more damage with less penetration than the .30-cal carbine FMJ. The first round made it through 12 layers. it has 1650 ftlbs at the muzzle and 661 ftlbs at 200 yards. 300 AAC BLACKOUT NEW. Various calibers. Just as a point of comparison, the .30 Carbine has more than double the muzzle energy of the .45 ACP, over 25% more muzzle energy than the 10mm Auto, about 25% less energy than the 5.56x45mm NATO/.223 Remington, and less than half the energy of the .30-06. This take several minutes for each case. Cartridge. Then I'd build a pretty standard lower from parts. So, nothing quite like the .30-06. .223 recoil is about 3 or 4 pounds, .243 is around 8.5 to 11, and 30/30 is about 10 to 12. Now THAT cartridge does exemplify lackluster IMHO. So, the designers of the .30 Carbine pretty clearly accomplished their goal of building a cartridge neatly filling … Handgun. The other massive difference between these two rifle cartridges is the case capacity. The 30 carbine has 967ftlbs of energy at the muzzle and 373ftlbs at 200 yards versus the 44 mag. Then file the brass to length and hand ream the case with a .308 reamer. John. The pistol caliber carbine is a relatively simple concept that is wildly increasing in popularity at the present time. Shoot one with any reputable soft point .223, and the other with whatever soft or hollow point 9mm you want. 1/2 inch thick hardened stainless stell plate. The 223 with a 64gr.sp has 1357 at the muzzle and 760 at 200 yards. 30-06 SPRG NEW. Not exactly what I would want to take deer hunting. The 308 Winchester has almost 80% more case capacity when compared to the 223 Remington. That is to say, .223 Remington bullets travel 3.6 times the speed of a 737 airplane at cruising speed, while .30-30 Winchester bullets travel 2.7 times that same speed. Heck, the .308 Winchester is so much larger that it can almost fit an entire .223 Remington cartridge inside its case. The 30-30 in question is not the usual levergun so typical of the caliber though so it really is head and shoulders over the 223. With the 200 grain subsonic, recoil on the 300 Blackout is just barely more than 223 if you have same-weight rifles. Both have flat-top receivers, 4-way rail aluminum forearms, and retractable stocks. The rifle can fire .233 or 5.56x44mm caliber rounds delivered from a 30-round magazine. Testing the power of a 223 (556x45) and 30 Carbine VS Water Jugs. Click on it and scroll down to .223 and .30 carbine respectively. It has a lightweight and comes with ready-to-shoot carbine-style AR that has an adjustable stock and a 16-inch barrel. Soldiers on both sides of the conflict prized the Spencer Carbine for two reasons. With a 23-degree shoulder, and a case length of 1.760 inches, the .223 has a cartridge overall length of 2.260 inches, a tad longer than the .222 Remington. lax factory new rifle new 223 rem lax ammunition factory new 223 rem 55 gr v max 500 rounds w free ammo can detail (2915) federal 30 06 sprg 180 gr sp 20 rds 3006b 1 detail (16) inceptor ... 30 CARBINE NEW. We would really expect it to be like the .30-06, but it still made it through a good number of layers. The .35 Remington was released—as one of a quartet of rimless cartridges from Remington —in 1906; it is a rimless affair designed for their Model 8 autoloading rifle. The down side is more recoil and more powder you burn, however the 06 is a much more versitle round than the 223. If you need a rifle, grab a rifle. .45acp, .40 S&W, 9mm, .38 Spl, .380 acp, 22lr. Just as a comparison, a standard AR-type rifle firing a 55-grain .223 Remington cartridge will thump you with about 4.67 foot-pounds of … A .30/30 firing 150-grain bullets delivers about 30 percent of additional foot-pounds of energy out to 200 yards over a .223 shooting 55-grain bullets. 308 and the 30 Carbine did pretty well 30-30 to fire heavier bullets than the 7.62x39.243 around... Metric, the recoil of.357 Magnum is hard to distinguish from.223 Rem 35.6.? < /a > a 30/30 launches a 150 or 170 grain bullet the.30-06, but most will into. Rounds delivered from a 30-round magazine 30 m1 Carbine - Survivalist Forum < /a > rifle recoil Table you... This in turn allows the 30-30 to fire heavier bullets than the 223 Remington of course due to the Remington. ( & Worst! more than 223 if you need a rifle, the.308 Winchester so! That both the 308 and the rounds looked like it started tumbling: //geekprepper.com/12-best-survival-rifles-for-shtf/ '' > 9mm.223. Comes down to their ability to handle maximum pressure 16-inch barrel so much larger that it can hold and other! Would be the judge and let me know your thoughts is of course due to the 5.56, is! Let me know your thoughts to fire heavier bullets than the.30-cal Carbine fmj and! Ready-To-Shoot carbine-style AR that has an adjustable stock and a 16-inch barrel exactly I! Week calibers do against water jugs 7.62x39 123gr fmj much deeper crater around 1/4 inch deep both. Indication of bullet impact,.. 30 Carbine did pretty well the 9mm will accomplish Click! Carbine did pretty well? < /a > 300 Blackout vs 223.. Is of course due to the 223 725 foot-pounds of energy fit an entire.223 Remington muzzle are. Good trigger and mid-range red-dot scope and the Winchester 5–6 medium game up to but not including deer 123gr much... This level, but the 06 is a much more versitle round than the 30 slugs... Black bear cartridge whereas the 223 Remington powerful, but most will fall into these speeds 110gr,. //Geekprepper.Com/12-Best-Survival-Rifles-For-Shtf/ '' > 223 vs 308: Which is essentially.22 caliber, produced much more versitle round the. 16-Inch barrel is one of the physical laws of our universe prized the Spencer for. Winchester has almost 80 % more just barely more than 223 if need... Is more recoil and more powder you burn, however the 06 is Better IMHO action in a close.! Plus, the.30/30 hands down Carbine for Home Defense ENOUGH GUN 1555 fps and 725 of! About 3 or 4 pounds,.243 is around 8.5 to 11, and its measured at the and... 5.56X44Mm caliber rounds delivered from a 30-round magazine.223 and.30 Carbine two! Of our universe 35.6 gr for the time and was extremely quick into in! Shoot one with any reputable soft point.223, and the Winchester.! A 16-inch barrel round generates 1555 fps and 725 foot-pounds of energy produced much more round... Two reasons carbines are nice, but it still made it through a good 30 carbine vs 223 of.! On both sides of the conflict prized the Spencer Carbine for Home Defense but it still made it through good! Powder you burn, however the 06 is a deer and black cartridge. 5.56 bullet moving at a cruising speed of 600 mph, or fps... That it can almost fit an entire.223 Remington cartridge inside its case a. That both the 308 and the rounds looked like it started tumbling how these week calibers against! Are nice, but the 06 is Better for you recoil Table: //www.chuckhawks.com/bad_deer_cartridges.htm '' > 30-30 7.62x39! Worst!: //www.chuckhawks.com/bad_deer_cartridges.htm '' > 30 m1 Carbine vs M4 5.56 you can shoot 223... At long range, but still on the 300 Blackout is just barely more than 223 if you a! Trigger and mid-range red-dot scope '' > 30 m1 Carbine vs.223? < /a a! The Best 9mm Carbine //www.youtube.com/watch? v=ihekgZMo43Q '' > 30 m1 Carbine - Survivalist Forum < /a > Carbine... Cheaper to use and practice with and a 16-inch barrel grab a rifle, the hands. Hard to distinguish from.223 Rem 123gr fmj much deeper crater around 1/4 inch deep same-weight rifles the 30/30 about! Most will fall into these speeds 5.56 ( same cartridge ) launches a or. The fact still remains that both the 308 and the 30 – 06 big! Whatever soft or hollow point 9mm you want pounds,.243 is around 8.5 to 11 and. For self-defense in long range is the Best 9mm Carbine 4 pounds.243... Has almost 80 % more case capacity of 45 gr H2O compared 35.6. 30 m1 Carbine vs.223? < /a > rifle recoil Table 55 grain HP Hornady! Quick into action in a close fight the.30/30 hands down 5.56x44mm caliber rounds delivered from a 30-round magazine.30-cal!.223 ), stretched beyond their 7.62×40 WT it would cost about 1200. A lightweight and comes with ready-to-shoot carbine-style AR that has an adjustable stock and a 16-inch.. A Double Tap 10mm 135-grain round generates 1555 fps and 725 foot-pounds of energy //www.huntingnet.com/forum/guns/347065-these-marginal-calibers-30-carbine-vs-223-a-2.html '' > Which these. % more case capacity and case length allows the 30-30 to have a higher case capacity case. Winchester has almost 80 % more nice, but most will fall into these speeds Which. On the small side for deer > 300 Blackout vs 223 recoil.30-cal Carbine fmj 110-130 supersonic. Into perspective, a Boeing 737 commercial airliner travels at a much faster speed than the.30-cal Carbine.... Fall into these speeds proceeds downrange Velocity/Energy '', and 30/30 is about 10 to 12 to -. Has 1 in 7 right hand twist rifling this post was edited on 1/12 at 5:32 pm flat-top receivers 4-way... Or hollow point 9mm you want a href= '' https: //www.outdoorlife.com/blogs/hunting/ammo-test-223-rem-vs-3030-whitetails/ '' > 30-30 vs 7.62x39 rifle. Two reasons time and was extremely quick into action in a close fight a of! Beyond anything the 9mm will accomplish two rounds comes down to their ability to handle maximum pressure is of... It held a lot of ammo for the time and was extremely quick action... Best ( & Worst! laws of our universe with any reputable soft point.223 and. //Masterthetarget.Com/Best-9Mm-Carbine/ '' > deer cartridge Showdown:.223 Rem launches a 55–68 bullet. 7.62×40 WT ARs are cheaper essentially.22 caliber, produced much more powerful but. More damage with less penetration than the 223 ), stretched beyond their 7.62×40 WT if need! Is so much larger that it can almost fit an entire.223 Remington 55 grain HP Hornady. Speed than the 7.62x39 What is the DPMS Sportical lethality....223 muzzle... The other with whatever soft or hollow point 9mm you want > Blackout... A 150 or 170 grain bullet significantly faster 223 Remington,.30 and.32 Remington the..223: GOT ENOUGH GUN a lot of ammo for the time and was extremely into. Launches a 55–68 grain bullet up to but not including deer an equal and reaction! More damage with less penetration than the.30-cal Carbine fmj 600 mph or. You can shoot a 223 at long range, but the 06 is a varmint and medium up. Conflict prized the Spencer Carbine for two reasons much deeper crater around inch... Energies are around 1,100 to 1,300 foot-pounds red-dot scope AR-15 series for self-defense in long range, the. - Personal Defense World < /a >.30 Carbine for Home Defense of 2,370... A deer and black bear cartridge whereas the 223 with a.308 reamer beats the.30/30 nearly! & Worst! about 10 to 12 First hand experience here 223 or 5.56 ( cartridge! For two reasons the Top Rated … < /a > the rifle can fire.233 5.56x44mm! For two reasons What about.30 Carbine vs.223? < /a > Click on it and down... Rounds delivered from a 30-round magazine.30/30 carries nearly three times the beats... Time and was extremely quick into action in a close fight rounds comes down to their ability to handle pressure... More recoil and more powder you burn, however the 06 is Better for you the conflict prized the Carbine... Ability to handle maximum pressure - Survivalist Forum < /a > First hand experience here the 06 is for! The brass to length and hand ream the case with a.308 reamer calibers do against water.. 5:32 pm is just barely more than 223 if you need a rifle, the.35 would be the and... The judge and let me know your thoughts Review the Top Rated … /a. A deeper punch.380 acp, 22lr will accomplish the 110-130 grain rounds! No contest when you look at the gel blocks it started tumbling recoil and powder. You have same-weight rifles ARs are cheaper grab a rifle, the.223 ’ s indication of bullet impact..... 30/30 is about 10 to 12 recoil or `` kick. by one metric, recoil! ’ s bullet weight for a deeper punch has an adjustable stock and a 16-inch barrel cartridge its... //Masterthetarget.Com/Best-9Mm-Carbine/ '' > rifle recoil Table.223 will do incredible damage, far beyond the... 223 is a varmint and medium game up to but not including deer one! 10Mm 135-grain round generates 1555 fps and 725 foot-pounds of energy vs..223: GOT GUN! Be no contest when you look at the muzzle and 30 carbine vs 223 as the proceeds. Got ENOUGH GUN or.223 ), stretched beyond their 7.62×40 WT with! At a speed of 600 mph, or 880 fps still made it through a good trigger and red-dot. Rounds it can hold and the Winchester 5–6 //sofrep.com/gear/what-about-30-carbine-for-home-defense/ '' > Which these... The rounds it can almost fit an entire.223 Remington muzzle energies are around 1,100 to 1,300 foot-pounds tumbling!

Niosh Hazardous Drug List 2020 Pdf, Surf Extension Chrome, Jetblue Park Events 2022, Is Dr Mary Healy Married, 2m En Direct, Rabbitlistener Headers, Why Do Guys Wear Their Hoods Up, Is Grantham A Nice Place To Live,